Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Bill Stewart Dead From Apparent Heart Attack

Another Feaster Retread. Big Deal?


In short, no - it's not really a big deal.

But, it's getting a post anyway!

Why? Because I jump at the opportunity to point out that Jay Feaster is, and I'll be kinder than normal here, a terrible General Manager. I've laid it all out before but I'll sum it up quick like fox.

He inherited a Stanley Cup-calibre team in Tampa Bay, made a couple really nice depth moves (Sydor, Stillman for picks) and the team went on to win the cup. That's it for Feaster positives.

He then proceeded to sign everyone to terrible contracts, traded away all his stars for pennies on the dollar, traded draft pick after draft pick for bad players/contracts and drafted at a rate that could be beaten by a blindfolded monkey pointing to names on a piece of paper... sending the franchise into a tremendous Darryl Sutter-like spiral. But, his other fave thing to do in TBay and the reason my nervousness has escalated a tad today?

Bring back former players.

Read on if you dare.

Star-divide

Jay Feaster's track record did not exactly lend itself well to getting my confidence to be on his side. But, I figured I'd better give him a little time to see if he'd made some changes to his managerial style.

So I started to look for some of these indicators.

First, he acquired Freddy Modin, a former member of the Tampa Bay Lightning. This was his first move as GM and I was willing to chalk that up as a really cheap way to get some depth for the team's playoff push... but this went on to be nothing more than a trade that wasted a draft pick.

If you're scoring at home, that's 2 of 4 indicators hit within his first couple months on the job.

Then, he traded Regehr for pennies on the dollar and wasted a draft pick.

Then, he traded for P3L.... and wasted another draft pick.

And now, he's acquired another former member of the Tampa Bay Lightning in Blair Jones.

Listen, this isn't big news, it's not a big trade and maybe I'm just making something out of nothing to pass the time while my kid naps... doesn't matter... what matters is that he's doing the exact same things that led to his demise in Tampa.

I know he's done some other nice things and that's all well and good... but this trend bothers me, and until it's stopped (fired) or fixed (fired), you can count on these annoying reminders from yours truly.

As far as the trade itself goes... just read Arik's post from earlier today, he sums it up nicely - as does Justin's comment.

Now get back to enjoying your Friday and eventual weekend. Don't let this negative-nelly getcha down!

Comment 5 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Just a point of clarification. Feaster did not sign off on the Vinny contract which happened July 13, 2008.

http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/wire?section=nhl&id=3485442

Feaster stopped being GM in Tampa on July 11 – resigning two days earlier and highlighting interference from ownership as an issue. He still had several years on his contract.

http://www.cbc.ca/sports/hockey/story/2008/07/11/jay-feaster.html

But yeah the Richards trade was a stinker but Feaster was working with Tampa since 1998 and a part of building that team at least a little for 6 years prior to the Cup win.

Has he made stinker moves, yep but Comeau was clean win.

Consider contributing to Wiki if you can. It is has come a long way since its inception in quality and its founders have resisted attempts to commercialize it. Lets keep it alive with a few dollars each.

by Mitch Smith on Jan 6, 2012 2:58 PM PST reply actions  

Horak out of that Erixon debacle wasn’t bad either.

Consider contributing to Wiki if you can. It is has come a long way since its inception in quality and its founders have resisted attempts to commercialize it. Lets keep it alive with a few dollars each.

by Mitch Smith on Jan 6, 2012 2:59 PM PST reply actions  

Dumping Langkow for Stempy turned out to be a win too in my view.

The real tale is going to come down on trade deadline day. I expect / hope Feaster can sell like auctioneer on speed. It is this day that will give me an indication on him.

Consider contributing to Wiki if you can. It is has come a long way since its inception in quality and its founders have resisted attempts to commercialize it. Lets keep it alive with a few dollars each.

by Mitch Smith on Jan 6, 2012 3:02 PM PST reply actions  

Honestly, I’m kind of torn about Feaster… I think he’s done some good things since he’s gotten here… I kinda think his main problem is that he listens to Butter.

The Reggie trade was a clear loss, as was PLLL (idiocy… goons are available for free why the eff would you pay anything for them?) and Modin. But I think his other moves have been neutral or positive all things considered. I really think someone ought to buy him a copy of “Moneyball” and “The Extra 2%” as a late X-mas/early birthday present.

Bringing back guys he knows isn’t anything new… Daz did that all the time (which is worrying in and of itself).

by Parallex on Jan 6, 2012 3:09 PM PST reply actions  

I think you have to see Feaster for what he is, a lawyer and not a hockey guy. In Tampa you get the feeling Torts was telling him the hockey stuff and you get the same feeling that Butter is doing the same thing.

Regarding PL3 Brent mentioned to Feaster to go pick him up and Feaster did because he didn’t realize Brent was joking. That was a poll question from Flames Nation, it probably isn’t that far from the truth.

Feaster will take the credit and the heat for the failure but the real hockey wizard of Oz is probably Butter. The guy should be nervous and he isn’t in the slightest, despite coaches heads rolling all over the NHL. Brent has his plan and his target players but as he pulls the Feaster’s strings.

The only reason to keep Butter may be some kind of connection to Parise.

Consider contributing to Wiki if you can. It is has come a long way since its inception in quality and its founders have resisted attempts to commercialize it. Lets keep it alive with a few dollars each.

by Mitch Smith on Jan 6, 2012 3:28 PM PST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Calgary Flames.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Dsc03339_small
Sven, Sven, Sven Baertschi
Small
Roman Cervenka's Contract Structure and Why He's Worth Every Penny
Small
Erixon and Schultz.. The two bastards

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

37 - 29 - 16

Won 2


Certified Executives of the Office of Management

Photo_71_small Hayley

Officiants of the Bureau of Editing

E571c235251f6540d35494b73d613163_small Justin Azevedo

Ryan_small SO_RyanP

Dsc03339_small Mitch Smith

Bureaucrats

Luongo_small DownGoesLuongo

Redfordnewmanbutchcassidy19_small Scott Lepp

Mcinnismonday_small BookoflooB

381858_721102932987_120603131_37270080_1092957201_n_small LaToya12