High Tide Hockey: Some Things Are Just Terrifying
High Tide Hockey is a weekly column offering insights on various issues and events as well as consistent content. The writer, Arik Knapp, is a member of the USCG and currently stationed in Virginia Beach, VA.
Adrian Aucoin terrifies me. Okay, not the player himself, but the story he tells here as reported by Eric Francis. I know I got on a bit of a soapbox last week regarding suspensions and such, but this is less of a political issue regarding the league, and more of a "be terrified" issue regarding the Flames.
Concussions are hard to diagnose. They are not, however, hard to recognize. A guy gets hit in the head- he’s dizzy, he’s woozy, he’s not really responsive to external stimuli. And yet somehow two years ago, Adrian Aucoin had a few of these and was completely missed by the Calgary Flames trainer.
If you read here, you’ll note that a properly licensed athletic trainer is just as capable of recognizing concussion symptoms as a doctor. The guy goes on for a bit about how poor trainers aren’t the cause of concussions and doctors won’t fix it. That’s not my issue with the Aucoin article.
My issue is the implication that it took two players (Craig Conroy and Michael Cammalleri) to recognize the symptoms. The Flames trainer either looked at him and thought he was okay or was told to ignore the collision that caused the concussion at first.
Both of those possibilities are terrifying. To my knowledge, there has not been any turnover in the Flames medical department. I could be completely wrong, as there’s not a lot of detail on the medical personnel, but any trainer worth his salt is going to look at the player and go through the basic concussion tests. Unless they’re told to do otherwise.
And that’s what worries me. Is, or was, there an attitude amongst Flames management that said "Unless blood is pouring out his ears make him play"? Because that’s pretty awful.
Imagine if Aucoin’s condition hadn’t been caught by the esteemed Mr. Conroy. Imagine if Aucoin goes back onto the ice and just gets bumped in the head with a concussion already in place. That takes a bad thing and makes it significantly worse.
Unless the medical staff was hired from a correspondence school based out of Colombia, I highly doubt that this is on them. Given former coach Mike Keenan’s reputation (the coach at the time of this incident), it wouldn’t surprise me if he told the trainer that Aucoin was fine and to stay away.
Of course, this quote from the Eric Francis article sticks out too:
You have a personal relationship with the trainer and they’re looking out for your best interest, but you argue with them on the bench," he laughed.
"Whereas a doctor, it’s his livelihood. You only argue the minute he leaves."
Give the trainers absolute medical power. Don’t let them take no from a player. And especially don’t let them take no from a coach. If the trainer sees concussion symptoms, that player needs to be off the bench and into the locker room immediately. Don’t blame trainers on this. Blame the lack of awareness by coaches or players.
-
The factoid that Ryan Lambert dug up on his What We Learned this week was amazing: Teemu Selanne was a kindergarten teacher. Just awesome.
-
Loved the bizarreness that is Cory Sarich being the only positive Flame in scoring chances against PHX the other night. Purely a statistical oddity propelled by cushy zone starts, but still entertaining.
-
The potential Vezina show down between NSH and BOS is going to be awesome. Though I hope Nashville loses.
-
More nasty hits lately. Not good. It just needs to stop.
-
Flames are theoretically going to fit under the salary cap. I’m still worried we’ll have another "OH GOD OH GOD HOW MANY PLAYERS ARE WE DRESSING TONIGHT????" end of the season though.
-
I hate the unwillingness of the league to really address headshots and dangerous hits. It’s a goddamn joke at this point. Just ridiculous.
-
It really bothers me that Hart voters don’t actually look at quality of play, but rather just gaudy stats. Looks like Sedin vs. Stamkos for the Hart. Should be Kesler vs. Toews.
- (This will continually be posted until I don’t need to anymore) I don’t want to hear another thing about the Phoenix Coyotes. Just let the deal happen, let them stay, and call it good. Winnipeg is no better of a market, and if the Coyotes ever got the quality management and ownership to build a fanbase, they could be far more successful. If the Yotes move to Winnipeg, we’ll be hearing this exact same thing happen in 5 years and then see them move to Seattle or New Orleans or something. And so on.
After a pretty bad February, T.J. Brodie has picked up his scoring again. I’d still rather see a two way defender like Erixon on the Flames next year though.
SO LIKE I GOT THESE RAD NEW GOLF CLUBS. CAN’T WAIT TO USE THEM BROSEPHS.
6 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
A friend of mine is a trainer in CGY at fairly high level in amateur hockey. He’s told me stories about having to argue with players and coaches about stuff like injuries knees, shoulders and concussions.
“So he’s okay right?”
“No. He’s incredibly injured.”
“He looks alright to me.”
“He’s not…”
“I think he can play tomorrow…”
etc.
Imagine what it’s like at the NHL level.
Sorry, Mr. College Douche. You’ll have to wait until June to use those new clubs of yours.
We know two things: Shitty Hockey and Booze.
Go Flames Go!
I think all sports, especially Football anyway, have the issue of players wanting to play through injury.
(1) I don’t have a lot of respect for Francis as a journalist. He always seems to be out for the TMZ version of events. The more controversial the better for him.
(2) The Flames are a highly respected organization – I invite anyone to find comments from former players slagging the organization in any manner – if the Flames were not a great organization to play for I doubt we would see players like Tangs and Jokinen return. This is a concussion issue is grey territory that is not as clear cut as he claims, he has a bit of mud he seems to be throwing in this article.
The Flames are no more or less in the dark on the concussion issue than any other team in the NHL.
On concussions, improvements will continue, a proper chain of command on calling a player out of the game will come into being.
Again, old school hockey, had players playing through it. Hockey has a mantra of toughness in its history. A sport where players rarely have their teeth and where most have known a TKO hit.
Concussions suck, but do they kill you? I think I probably had one maybe two but I just don’t see why there is a sky is falling mentality about them. Part of playing the game but again – patience for the old guy in the room.
Things are obviously changing. If only Crosby hadn’t taken that concussion we would probably not have such a crisis on our hands. Another reason for me not to like him sigh
If we are going to get on a high horse about Concussions in Hockey though I think we should really drop the gloves and get up on the soundbox about banning Boxing as a sport completely because that sport is the King of Concussions, no one seems concerned about that one…
As far as Francis goes, I agree with you there. Don’t like the guy one bit, always comes across as a bit of a snake. That said, this article was actually straight reporting.
I doubt it was so much malicious as it was negligent. The fact is, when a player takes a blow to the head of some sort, they need to be checked. And Aucoin wasn’t, for whatever reason.
Also, lots of players took shots at Keenan.
I didn’t realize how bad concussions were until I met a guy a few months ago who just through concussions had severe brain damage. Physical injuries are one thing- but something that can mess up your brain? Hell no. That’s not something to take even a small chance with.
Yeah, I don’t like Crosby much either, but he never really affected my attention to the subject at hand- more or less. It’s not just about the NHL players who get the best care in the world. It’s the AHL scrubs, the ECHL guys.
And boxing- never followed it, watched it, etc. But there should be more precautions there I agree. From my understanding bare knuckle/no pads would make it much safer. I’ve seen Raging Bull like ten times though!

by 























