Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Relegation Simulation: Rewriting College Football History

Flames Trade Ian White, Brett Sutter to the Hurricanes

After a lengthy buildup of speculation during the Flames' recent slide, the team has finally made a move, dealing defenceman Ian White, acquired in the January the deal that sent Dion Phaneuf to the Maple Leafs, to the Carolina Hurricanes. The package also includes 23-year-old Brett Sutter, and brings back defenceman Anton Babchuk and forward Tom Kostopoulos in return. After two separate stints in Russia, Babchuk, a native of the Ukraine, returned to the 'Canes this summer and has three goals and eight points in 17-games so far this season.

While Babchuk is similar to White in his skill set as an offensive defenceman and has been used as a comparable to White in terms of ability vs. cap hit, the advantage he does have is his size--Babchuk towers over White at 6 ft. 5, 212 lbs. I won't hesitate to say that the Flames' defence has been struggling and was perhaps in need of a shake-up, and White seemed like he would likely bring back the best return while not being overly expensive or difficult to replace, but only time will tell if this move was the right one. White was clearly struggling in the circumstances he was being used in, playing alongside Regehr in a shut-down, tough-minutes role, and could probably benefit from playing against easier competition, depending on what Carolina's depth chart looks like. 

Tom Kostopoulos is a player of little value to this team, perhaps equal or lesser to what Brett Sutter meant to the organization. A relatively marginal NHLer and a career minus player, Kostopoulos has managed to stick around in the league for eight seasons largely on the basis of his reputation as somewhat of an enforcer, playing for four other teams before coming to the Flames. He has one goal and four points this season to go along with 30 PIMS. With Ales Kotalik potentially close to returning in early December, the deal saves the Flames approximately $1M in cap space, as the 26-year-old Babchuk comes at a reasonable $1.4M (via CapGeek), and is a UFA after this season. Kostopoulos rakes in a cool $916,667 for the next two seasons. 

I would imagine it's highly doubtful that either player will join the team for tonight's game against the Coyotes (7:30 MT at the 'Dome), but the Flames do have some extra bodies hanging around in Staios/Mikkelson and Meyer/Conroy, so they won't exactly be shorthanded.  

Comment 11 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

This whole trade doesn’t change much in my mind. Sutter wasn’t earning playing time and White was a middle-of-the-road d-man so far this year. Kostopoulous and Babchuk are similar.

Take a look at this comparison between White and Babchuk.

White: 1.42 Corsi/60, 53.2% Zn Strt, -1.37 Corsi QoC, 6.38 Corsi QoT
Babs: -1.64 Corsi/60, 55.3% Zn Strt, -2.18 Corsi QoC, -0.05 Corsi QoT

With a little bit easier ice time but much worse teammates, Babchuk has a slightly worse possession stats than White.

Kostopoulos is more capable of playing in the NHL right now than Brett Sutter, but neither is exciting anyone.

The biggest upside for the Flames is that they clear about $1.2 million worth of cap space annually, so roughly $1m for the remainder of the year. That said, Babchuk is a UFA after this year just like White was.

Feaster mentioned that they knew they couldn’t sign White long term after signing Giordano so maybe they figure Babchuk is more likely to re-sign, or they’re clearing cap space for another move in-season.

Ryan

Matchsticks & Gasoline, Sports Opinionated, Pink Shirt Wise Guys: Italian Soccer Podcast & occasionally even Puck Prospectus. Apparently I have commitment problems.

by SO_RyanP on Nov 17, 2010 3:53 PM PST reply actions  

another move in-season.

Bingo-Bango-Boingo. There aren’t enough savings here for any major move on July 1st.

The 4th Line Blog
Go Flames Go

by Justin Azevedo on Nov 17, 2010 4:28 PM PST up reply actions  

I think the biggest reason for the space clearing is making room for Kotalik’s return (blech).

Still, of all the moves to make, THIS is the one Sutter picks?

by ArikJames on Nov 17, 2010 4:52 PM PST reply actions  

Definitely, just added a link to Feaster’s comments on Kotalik possibly returning in early Dec.
I don’t know; I’m kind of apathetic about it for the time being. Not a major improvement and but not a major downgrade either, and saves us some $.

by Hayley on Nov 17, 2010 5:11 PM PST up reply actions  

Not one to defend the relatively indefensible trading behaviour of daz, but we don’t know that there are actually other (better) moves to be made right now with this team.

D

by d_p_h on Nov 17, 2010 5:13 PM PST up reply actions  

Does Sutter firing himself and his brother count? That’d be a great move.

by ArikJames on Nov 17, 2010 5:15 PM PST up reply actions  

not really a deal.

by d_p_h on Nov 17, 2010 6:17 PM PST up reply actions  

True enough. I’m not sure if people expected more for White or are just disappointed to see him go because of the fact that he was one of the main pieces coming back in the Phaneuf trade, but I don’t know that they could have gotten much more for him. As for Brett Sutter, it’s probably a bigger loss for Abby than it is for the Flames. To be fair, we haven’t even seen the guys play yet.

by Hayley on Nov 17, 2010 5:35 PM PST up reply actions  

White may have had some value as a rental player to a team that needed blueline depth for a playoff push, but at most the return would be a young 3rd liner or something like that. It was clear that Calgary wasn’t keeping him past this year.

You’re right about the Phaneuf deal though. I don’t think anyone is thrilled that the most lasting piece of the Dion deal is Stajan at $3.5m per year.

Ryan

Matchsticks & Gasoline, Sports Opinionated, Pink Shirt Wise Guys: Italian Soccer Podcast & occasionally even Puck Prospectus. Apparently I have commitment problems.

by SO_RyanP on Nov 17, 2010 5:40 PM PST up reply actions  

Apathy

why is that my dominating feeling for this team, regardless of what is happening with them?

by brisulph on Nov 18, 2010 4:29 AM PST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Calgary Flames.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Dsc03339_small
Sven, Sven, Sven Baertschi
Small
Roman Cervenka's Contract Structure and Why He's Worth Every Penny
Small
Erixon and Schultz.. The two bastards
Small
Go Flames

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

37 - 29 - 16

Won 2


Certified Executives of the Office of Management

Photo_71_small Hayley

Officiants of the Bureau of Editing

E571c235251f6540d35494b73d613163_small Justin Azevedo

Ryan_small SO_RyanP

Dsc03339_small Mitch Smith

Bureaucrats

Luongo_small DownGoesLuongo

Redfordnewmanbutchcassidy19_small Scott Lepp

Mcinnismonday_small BookoflooB

381858_721102932987_120603131_37270080_1092957201_n_small LaToya12